When it comes to having a gas supply to heat or cook in a static caravan, the choice between gas cylinders and piped gas sparked plenty of discussion among owners.
Last month we asked static caravanners: Do you have gas cylinders or a piped gas connection at your static caravan?
With 663 votes cast the results are in, with two-thirds of voters telling us they used gas cylinders and almost a third saying they had a piped connection.
The poll also sparked a lively discussion, with 17 comments shedding light on the pros and cons of each static caravan gas supply.
Your static caravan gas supply comments
The case for gas cylinders
For many static caravan owners, gas cylinders are the standard. Adrian Benge noted that gas cylinders are still widely used at his holiday park, Naish.
Sue Ewings mentioned the simplicity of having two bottles ready for easy switching, while Trevor Southan highlighted their ease of maintenance.
However, some users flagged downsides. Peter Howard and Bryan Knox pointed out the increasing cost of cylinders and Bryan also mentioned that cylinder-fed hob burners are less efficient for simmering compared to piped gas.
Why choose piped gas?
For others, piped gas is a game-changer. Alan Bignall and Mick Wragg emphasised the convenience of not worrying about running out of gas or switching bottles. Mick also appreciated the ability to monitor usage through a meter.
Bryan Knox commented that piped gas offers better efficiency and control, particularly for cooking. Similarly, Mike Benham, who transitioned from cylinders to piped gas, described piped gas as cheaper, more convenient, and reliable.
Some owners shared details about alternative setups. Jeremy Collins described how his holiday park uses a central gas container filled by lorry delivery, which feeds around 30 units. He said this system was both convenient and good value.
Meanwhile, Neil Bailey pointed out that piped gas from a central storage tank as generally available only on newer or redeveloped sites.
Hazel raised an important question about the cost of piped gas per unit, reflecting a common concern among those considering a switch from cylinders to piped gas.
The static caravan gas supply verdict
The choice between gas cylinders and piped gas often comes down to personal preference and the site infrastructure. For holiday-only parks, gas cylinders might suffice. However, for those living in static caravans for most of the year, or in newer developments, piped gas seems to be the preferred choice.
Do you agree with the majority? Let us know what you make of the results by commenting below.
We currently have bottle gas. Part of the site has gas from central tank. My preference would be gas from the central tank. More convenient and a much tidier look to the site.
We don’t have a choice we are held to ransom on gas bottles we have two they are useless for cooking thank god for air fryers we have every year price increase when I first brought my van it was £60 each now it’s £90 and it won’t stop there nice little side line for site manager
I have gas cylinders which is fine the only thing that bugs me is the site owner charged £110 per bottle my friend who has a van at Blackpool gets his gas for £90 I stay on Clayton caravan park we have a swimming pool but it is open to the public we also have to pay for that we get it for 50pence cheaper the caravans are also over priced
How much are people paying for a 47 kg bottle? We pay £72
Cost has to be a relevant factor, a 47kg bottle may last 6 to 8weeks, you know the cost, you may only spend that tome a year in your holiday home…a piped system will involve an installation charge, a daily service charge and the cost of the gas per cu metre…cost has to be the leader here
2x large gas bottles lasted 37 days starting on the 18/11/24 covering the period to the 29/12/24, with some quite cold weather. But first time living in a static, so will see over the full year of 2025, intend to live on site for full 45 weeks it’s open, with odd days away. A mate down the road in Knaresborough pays £10 a bottle less. Gas has to be bought from my site only. Lived previously in 4 bed house in Bradford before sale and moving. Paid £65 a month DD with Britgas so can’t really compare, as new Willerby Brookwood green is only 2 bed and far smaller.